Loading market data...

DOJ Tells Judge Failla Bitcoin Fog Ruling Backs Tornado Cash Venue

DOJ Tells Judge Failla Bitcoin Fog Ruling Backs Tornado Cash Venue

Federal prosecutors asked Judge Katherine Polk Failla on October 5 to treat a D.C. Circuit decision on Bitcoin Fog as supplemental authority supporting venue in the Roman Storm case, arguing the ruling undermines Storm's attempt to throw out the money laundering and unlicensed money transmitting counts on jurisdictional grounds. The three-page letter, docket 305 in United States v. Roman Storm, is the government's latest effort to keep both counts in the Southern District of New York ahead of sentencing.

The Sterlingov ruling and why it matters here

The appeals court in United States v. Sterlingov, decided September 25, found venue proper for a money laundering conspiracy charge because transfers to and from Bitcoin Fog furthered the mixer's ability to launder funds for all users — not just the individual depositor. It also upheld venue for an unlicensed money transmitting charge on the grounds that Bitcoin Fog had served customers in the district.

Prosecutors say both holdings map directly onto the Tornado Cash evidence introduced at Storm's trial. The heart of their argument is that a single user's activity in Manhattan is enough: the government points to Shakeeb Ahmed, identified in the filing as a Tornado Cash user who was in the Southern District of New York when he transacted with the protocol. Ahmed testified he accessed Tornado Cash from his apartment in Manhattan, which prosecutors say establishes that the protocol served customers in the district.

Ahmed's deposit and the anonymity set

Storm's defense had argued that Ahmed's funds stayed in Tornado Cash too briefly to materially further the alleged conspiracy. The government now has a counterweight. In Sterlingov, the depositor made two small deposits — one about $250, a second roughly 0.0117 Bitcoin, worth about $97 at the cited closing price — withdrew almost all of the first the next day, and withdrew the second within three days. The D.C. Circuit still found sufficient evidence for a jury to conclude those transfers furthered Bitcoin Fog's laundering capability for all users.

Ahmed testified his deposit remained in Tornado Cash for "a couple days," which prosecutors call close in duration to the Sterlingov transactions. They also lean on trial witness Justin Bram, who testified that "the larger the anonymity set, the harder it would be to identify where funds came from and where they're going." About $400 million of cryptocurrency flowed through Bitcoin Fog, according to the facts cited in the filing.

Acknowledging thin Second Circuit precedent

The government concedes its law is "nearly silent" on materiality for venue in conspiracy cases. To bridge that gap, the letter cites United States v. Royer, where a handful of subscribers in the district supported venue for a stock-picking website with hundreds of subscribers. Prosecutors read Royer to require a relationship between the in-district acts and the conspiracy's object — not a larger quantitative threshold.

For Count Two, the government calls Sterlingov even more persuasive, noting the appeals court applied venue requirements for a substantive unlicensed money transmitting offense and found that serving customers in the district was enough, citing examples of receiving funds from and issuing funds to a person in Washington, D.C.

FinCEN backs off mixing rule

The venue fight lands the same week FinCEN moved in the other direction on mixer policy. In a notice scheduled for publication on October 6, the bureau withdrew its finding that international convertible virtual currency mixing is a class of transactions of primary money laundering concern, and withdrew the related proposed rule under Section 311 of the USA PATRIOT Act. That 2023 proposal would have required covered financial institutions to report specified details when they knew, suspected, or had reason to suspect a transaction involved mixing outside the United States — including the amount and type of cryptocurrency, the mixer used, wallet addresses, transaction hashes, transaction dates, IP addresses, and a narrative description.

The court has not adopted the government's venue conclusion in docket 305. The letter is a request that Judge Failla find venue proper on Counts One and Two, and no ruling has followed. Whether the judge accepts the Sterlingov analogy — particularly the government's reading of materiality and its reliance on a single Manhattan user — is the next concrete question in the case.