Federal prosecutors asked Judge Katherine Polk Failla on Monday to reject Roman Storm's attempt to move his money-laundering and money-transmission conspiracy retrial out of Manhattan, pointing to a D.C. Circuit decision handed down Sept. 25 in a separate Bitcoin Fog case. The Tornado Cash co-founder is set to be retried on April 26, 2027, under an Aug. 25 scheduling order, while he still has one August 2025 conviction on a money-transmission conspiracy count hanging over him with a five-year statutory maximum.
The venue fight, and why Sterlingov matters
Storm's lawyers argue the Southern District of New York is the wrong place to try the remaining counts. The government's answer, filed Oct. 5, treats the D.C. Circuit's ruling in United States v. Sterlingov as persuasive authority that venue is proper here. That case involved Bitcoin Fog, another mixing service, and the prosecutors' brief uses it to shore up the argument that the alleged conduct touched Manhattan.
Their hook is a local one: Shakeeb Ahmed, a Manhattan customer whose deposits into Tornado Cash, the government says, helped enlarge the anonymity pool and made funds harder to trace. That single user is doing a lot of work in the venue analysis. Prosecutors need the court to accept that those deposits — mixed with legitimate ones — helped conceal criminal proceeds, which is not the same as saying every depositor knew what was going on.
Arad's distinction: knowledge versus code
At an April 9, 2026 hearing, prosecutor Ben Arad pushed back on the idea that Storm is being punished just for writing software. His framing: legitimate deposits helped hide criminal funds, and there's a difference between what an innocent depositor knew and what Storm and his alleged coconspirators knew. Judge Failla pressed the government on whether its broader theory actually establishes willful conduct. Arad's response focused on active steps to maintain and improve the service, not merely leaving its pools running.
That question — whether Storm's developer work crossed the criminal line — is the whole ballgame. DOJ describes his conduct as building, maintaining and profiting from a service despite knowing it moved criminal proceeds. Storm contests the criminal treatment of his developer activity. Nothing in Monday's letter resolves that; it's a venue argument, not a merits ruling.
FinCEN backs off its 2023 mixer finding
On the same day, Treasury's FinCEN moved to withdraw its 2023 finding and proposed enhanced reporting and recordkeeping requirements for international cryptocurrency mixing. The notice, filed Oct. 5 for Oct. 6 publication, cites concerns about a "chilling effect on legitimate activity" and the burden on financial institutions. It does not repeal any criminal offense and it does not decide Storm's case. But the timing is hard to ignore: the enforcement agency's policy shop is walking back a mixer-specific rule while the Justice Department keeps a mixer developer on the docket.
Storm, posting as @rstormsf, framed the stakes in personal terms, describing potential imprisonment as punishment "for writing code" and contrasting his situation with Treasury's retreat. That's his read. The government's read is that he wasn't just writing code.
The policy memos that don't cover him
Two internal DOJ guidance documents are likely to come up as the retrial approaches. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche's April 7, 2025 memo steered prosecutors away from targeting mixers for users' conduct or unwitting regulatory violations — but it expressly excludes section 1960(b)(1)(C), which covers funds known to come from crime or intended for unlawful activity. Then in August 2025, DOJ official Matthew Galeotti added protection against new charges under that same subsection for qualifying software that is truly decentralized, solely automates peer-to-peer transactions, and leaves the third party without custody and control over user assets.
Storm's defense will argue his software fits. Prosecutors will argue the carve-outs don't reach the charged conduct. Trump's Jan. 21, 2025 pardon of Ross Ulbricht granted individual clemency for specified convictions; it did not extend to Storm or create a general exemption for crypto developers, so that avenue is closed.
What's next: Failla has to rule on the venue challenge, and the April 26, 2027 retrial date stands unless the pending acquittal motion changes the schedule. The Sterlingov comparison will be tested in that ruling.



