A federal judge acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the MIT-educated brothers accused of defrauding Ethereum trading bots out of $25 million in 2023, closing the U.S. government's first criminal case over maximal extractable value. The judge found the brothers' trade involved no lie that anyone relied on — adding, in a line that will travel, that Ethereum has "no terms of use."
The decision lands as a straight legal blow to a theory prosecutors had been testing for over a year: that exploiting MEV, the profit extracted by reordering or sandwiching on-chain transactions, can be prosecuted as wire fraud. The court said it can't, at least not on these facts.
What the brothers actually did
Prosecutors said the Peraire-Buenos set up a scheme in 2023 to bait Ethereum trading bots into trades the brothers could then exploit, walking away with roughly $25 million. The government framed it as fraud. The defense framed it as a trade. The judge sided with the second framing on the narrow question of whether anyone was misled.
The acquittal turned on reliance. Fraud requires a victim who believed something untrue and acted on it. The judge ruled there was no such lie in the Peraire-Bueno trade. The bots weren't deceived by a false statement — they executed against market conditions, and the market conditions were what the brothers manipulated.
The 'no terms of use' line
That phrase is the ruling's most quotable moment and its most consequential. By stating flatly that Ethereum has no terms of use, the judge undercut the idea that on-chain activity happens inside a contractual framework the government can police with fraud statutes. There's no user agreement to breach. No fine print to violate.
For prosecutors, that's a problem. Wire fraud charges lean on deception. If the platform has no rules of engagement, the legal ground for calling a trade a lie gets thin.
The MEV gray zone stays gray
MEV has been one of crypto's most uncomfortable open secrets. Sandwich attacks, frontrunning, and the broader practice of reordering transactions for profit are widely condemned by users and widely tolerated by the protocols where they happen. Nobody has agreed on whether it's theft, arbitrage, or just the cost of doing business on a public chain.
This ruling doesn't answer that question. It says criminal fraud law isn't the tool to answer it — at least not when the alleged deception is aimed at bots rather than people.
What comes next
The acquittal closes the first criminal MEV case, but it doesn't settle the practice's legal status. Civil suits against MEV operators are still viable in theory, and regulators can pursue other theories. Whether the government appeals the ruling — and whether prosecutors try again with a different fact pattern — is the open question now.
For the Peraire-Bueno brothers, the case is over. For everyone else running bots on Ethereum, the judge just made their world a little less legally certain, and a little more profitable.




