Loading market data...

Sixth Circuit Lets Ohio and Tennessee Enforce Gambling Laws Against Kalshi Sports Contracts

Sixth Circuit Lets Ohio and Tennessee Enforce Gambling Laws Against Kalshi Sports Contracts

A federal appeals court ruled on Sept. 25 that Ohio and Tennessee can enforce their gambling laws against Kalshi's sports contracts, handing the prediction-market platform a fresh legal setback as it fights similar battles in several states.

The Sixth Circuit's decision allows the two states to proceed with enforcement while Kalshi's broader legal challenge continues. The panel's reasoning leaned in part on statements Kalshi itself made in court, a detail that could complicate the company's arguments elsewhere.

What the Sixth Circuit decided

The ruling from the Cincinnati-based appeals court clears the way for Ohio and Tennessee regulators to act against Kalshi's sports-related event contracts. Kalshi has argued that its products are federally regulated financial instruments, not gambling, but the Sixth Circuit didn't accept that framing for the purpose of blocking state enforcement.

Kalshi's own courtroom statements featured in the panel's analysis, according to the ruling. That's an unusual twist: the company's litigation posture in one case is now being used to justify allowing state gambling laws to apply in two others.

Kalshi's multi-state fight is already split

The Sixth Circuit's decision adds to a growing patchwork of appellate outcomes. Kalshi's multi-state litigation has already produced a circuit split — meaning different appeals courts have reached different conclusions about whether states can enforce their gambling laws against the platform's sports contracts.

A circuit split raises the odds that the U.S. Supreme Court will eventually have to step in. For now, Kalshi faces a map where the rules depend on which circuit you're in.

New Jersey petition and the next deadline

Kalshi's legal calendar isn't letting up. The company's reply to New Jersey's Supreme Court petition is due, putting another state-level challenge on the near-term docket. New Jersey has been among the states pushing to apply its gambling laws to Kalshi's sports contracts.

The reply will give Kalshi a chance to argue why New Jersey's top court shouldn't take up the case — or, if it does, why the company should prevail. Either way, the filing will be closely watched by other states weighing similar enforcement moves.

For Kalshi, the Sixth Circuit ruling is a practical problem. Ohio and Tennessee can now move ahead with enforcement, which could mean restrictions on how the platform offers sports contracts to residents in those states.

The decision doesn't end the broader legal question of whether event contracts tied to sports outcomes are gambling or financial products. It just means two more states get to act while that question works its way through the courts.

Other states in the Sixth Circuit — Kentucky, Michigan, and Tennessee's neighbors — will be watching how Ohio and Tennessee use the authority the ruling gives them. Kalshi, meanwhile, has to decide how aggressively to keep litigating state by state while a circuit split widens and a Supreme Court petition from New Jersey sits pending.

The next concrete step is Kalshi's reply in the New Jersey matter. After that, the company's options narrow to either persuading the justices to stay out or preparing for a national-level fight.